Holiness in the Virtue & Vice Tradition
An Introduction to the Seven Deadly Sins
by Jeff Reimer
Feast of St John the Hut DwellerAnno Domini 2020, January 15
The list of seven capital vices (as I shall elect to call them) has, moreover, undergone several permutations throughout the centuries. They originate from the fourth-century desert father Evagrius of Pontus. An aristocratic, philosophically minded theologian living among largely (though by no means exclusively) illiterate peasant monks in the desert, Evagrius gave theoretical and systematic articulation to ascetic life in the Egyptian wilderness, categorizing the various forms of temptation and distilling what he called “the eight thoughts,” the often-unrecognized precurser to and fountainhead of one of Christianity’s most enduring moral legacies.
Evagrius’s list included gluttony, lust, avarice, wrath, sadness, acedia, vainglory, and pride. This list passed into the West via John Cassian, a Latin-speaking—and, crucially, Latin-writing—Christian who spent time in the desert with the first monks. In two works, the Institutes
and the Conferences, he summarized and elaborated on the desert tradition. These books were deeply influential in the Latin West, particularly because in his Rule
Benedict identified them by name as essential reading for all monks. Cassian called Evagrius’s eight thoughts the capital vices.
In the sixth century Pope Gregory the Great, writing for a non-monastic audience, did a little pruning and rearranging of the list, dropping pride (which he viewed as the taproot of all sin), adding envy, and incorporating acedia into sadness. His list has remained basically standard in the West ever since. In the twelfth century, however, Hugh of St. Victor made one seemingly small change: he re-substituted acedia for sadness—a happy occurrence, for to have subsumed acedia, the “complex thought,” as Evagrius called it, completely into sadness would have tragically vitiated our understanding of one of the most mercurial and vexing of the classic vices. He also called the list, for the first time, the seven capital sins. This is the fixed and definite form the list and its title took in the West, for it is this list and this title that was sitting in front of Thomas Aquinas (who thought it was Gregory’s) as he brought to bear upon it the force of his genius.
The capital vices are identified as such not because they are the most frequent or worst possible sins but because they are the source of all other sins. There is also a structure to them (I’m using Aquinas’s list): gluttony, lust, and avarice are sins of a carnal, animal, or material nature; while envy, vainglory, and wrath are of an immaterial, rational, or spiritual nature. Acedia lies at the juncture of our animal and rational natures, as Evagrius calls them, and thus acedia incorporates aspects of both forms of sin (which is why Evagrius called it the complex thought).
In the modern West when mention is made of the seven deadly sins it is largely to misunderstand them, thus inadvertently but inevitably promoting further moral confusion. The Christian condemnation of lust, for example, is assumed to entail a rejection of all sex, and the embrace of sexual desire in all its forms is taken to be a liberation of the body rather than its willing enslavement to a sinful passion. Envy and avarice foster economic growth, and we thereby celebrate greed. Sloth becomes leisure. Gluttons are gourmands. The purportedly high stakes of social (media) discourse justify vainglory and wrath.
If we do
recognize vice we psychologize it, both immanentizing sin and trivializing it in one deft motion. Thus gluttony is reduced to obesity and treated as a disease. Wrath is quieted by anger management; pride, amended by a proper sense of self-esteem.
If I seem a little dyspeptic it might be because I’m indulging in schadenfreude—a subspecies of envy—at observing the moral chaos of our culture. So let me turn the coin over and look at the other side: virtue.
*The rest of this essay will be printed in The Moot 2.1, available to all Eighth Day Patrons and Pillars, and released at the 10th annual Eighth Day Symposium on January 23-25. If you are not yet a member, we are offering 50% off Patron and Pillar memberships through the end of January. Sign up before the Symposium and attend free!
Share this Post on Your Preferred Platform
Oxymorons and the Cross
Warrior, Shepherd, Penitent, and Type of Christ
The Church in the World
A reflection for Orthodox Great and Holy Friday
A reflection for Good Friday
The Character of the Early Church
The Sisters of Sophia will gather on the Commemoration of the Great Martyr Theodore, Anno Domini 2026, February 17. Rachel Garton will present The Battlefield of Compassion: Florence Nightingale, Clara Barton, and St Verena . Sisters of Sophia When Every third Tuesday Where The Ladder 2836 E Douglas, Wichita Parking available behind Eighth Day Books Schedule Food, drink, and fellowship at 6:30pm Eighth Day Convocation & Lecture at 7:20pm Membership Required? No, but do consider joining the community! Learn more and join here !
The Hall of Men will gather Thursday evening on the commemoration of St Meletius, Archbishop of Antioch, Anno Domini 2026, February 12. David Beutel will present on St. John Henry Newman. St. John Henry Newman (21 February 1801 – 11 August 1890) was an English Catholic theologian, academic, philosopher, historian, writer, and poet. He was previously an Anglican priest, and after his conversion to Catholicism, became a cardinal. Newman's beatification was proclaimed by Pope Benedict XVI on 19 September 2010 during his visit to the United Kingdom. His canonization was officially approved by Pope Francis on 12 February 2019, and took place on 13 October 2019. Come and jo in us for the first toast of 2026 at the Hall of Men! If you haven’t seen a Catholic listen to the life story of John Wesley; if you haven’t watched a Protestant learn about Evagrius of Pontus; and if you haven’t seen Orthodox, Catholic, and Protestant men sit around a table together and talk theology until midnight . . . then you need to come to the Hall of Men. When The commemoration of St Meletius, Archbishop of Antioch, Anno Domini 2026, February 12. Where The Ladder at 2836 E. Douglas, Wichita, KS 67214 Schedule Doors Open at 7 pm Food is served at 7:30pm Eighth Day Convocation at 8:30pm Presentation and toast by Derek Hale immediately following Convocation. Membership Required? No, but do consider joining the community! Learn more and join today here .
Reflections on the enduring validity of Malcolm Muggeridge's critiques of the media in the 1970s.
An Introduction to Charles Williams by Charles Hefling Commemoration of St Hosea the Prophet Anno Domini 2025, October 17
